In the case of any doubt, it's best to consult a trusted specialist. What J.K Rowling Doesn't Want You To Know About Harry Potter's ParentsSubscribe: http://bit.ly/Subscribe-to-Things DO YOU BELIEVE IN MAGIC | Potterheads: h. When Snape accidentally injures Petunia using magic, she calls Lily a "freak," while Lily reveals that she and Snape saw a letter that Petunia wrote, begging Hogwarts to accept her as a student. @ClaireVoyant: OMFH ROFLMMFAO Right on. Tobias was born sometime in the early twentieth century, into the Muggle Snape family. http://www.enotes.com/search?q=harry+potter. But he saves most of his venom for Harry, whom he punishes especially harshly. Welcome to r/HarryPotter, the place where fans from around the world can meet and discuss everything in the Harry Potter universe! I actually thought Snape was Harry's dad for a while. after the character's death. Harrys father is, was, and will always be James Potter. She said, flat-out, that Harry resembled no one in his family - and that he had "thick, messy black hair.". A Member of Townsquare Entertainment News. But the film version doesn't clearly show why their relationship fell apart the way it did. Continue Reading 347 Sponsored by Elated Stories Not this shit again! Snape showed Albus the doe after he asked Snape if he had developed feelings for Harry. Snape, once again, proved he was a hero by acting as a double agent, which was revealed the Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows. Snape already knew about the world of magic, and was, in some ways, a key figure in Lilys childhood. And, in the same way, we understand that good old Dumbledore wasnt quite as good as we thought he was. James is the one who ended up with Lily and married her thus conceiving Harry. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. If Snape was jealous of James, it would make sense such jealousy could result in disabling James, who essentially persecuted Snape during Hogwart's schooling. If by real you mean through genes the answer to that is James Potter. Who is Harry Potter's real father? I did not read books 5-7 so I'm not sure what they say. J. K. Rowlings, author of the Harry Potter series, went to a great deal of trouble creating unique characters who shared common connections. His mother was a witch and his father was a Muggle, leading to the moniker "The Half-Blood Prince." And that when he agrees to protect Harry he says no one can know. What Would 'Potter' Have Been Like With Tim Roth As Snape? Snape takes out all his past frustration on Harry, whom he sees as a reflection of his father and, consequently, as an enemy and rival. Instead of accepting her act of kindness, he rejected her and called her a "mudblood" an insult to witches and wizards with Muggle parents despite his own impure bloodline. Ultimately though, James rushed into action andmanaged to reach Snape before he could be fully exposed to Lupin. Is there such a thing as pure goodness? I'm not sure where people have got that idea. It doesnt talk about the question at all! Can We dream it? and I took Dumbledore's response as implying he was. Snape once made an appearance in an episode of the TV show. Snape is harry's biological father Follow . What are the main settings of Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets? Fortunately, Rowling always seems eager to fill in the blanks for her readers. Death Eater. But it would have been too complicated with where Harry's protection would come from instead. A Member of Townsquare Entertainment News. Severus Snape's infamous line about Harry Potter's eyes in Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part 2 isn't actually a Harry Potter plot hole. Snape did confront Harry about the missing ingredients for the potion. After Snape and Lily leave Hogwarts, the space between them only grows as Snape joins Voldemort, the Dark Lord, to help him overtake the wizarding world, while Lily . How much he loved her. "Is Severus Snape really Harry's dad?" However, if you've read the books or watched the films, you know there's much more to Severus Snape than meets the eye. She probably wasn't coming back down to Spinner's End ever again. We know that Snape has the dark mark, an indication that he was once a Death Eater. People tell me how it's more detailed but I get where and why people think snape is Harry's father. " I'm looking for Harry Potter" Snape said. We all shed a few tears when we discovered that, after all this time, Snape still loved Harrys mother Lily and that, in fact, everything he had done was to ensure the young mans safety. While the primary focus was on Harry Potter and his friends' time at Hogwarts, sections of the story hinted at events from decades earlier involving Harry's parents. Severus Snape is not Harry's father. They met as children and became great friends. It's especially bad since James has a penchant for bullying Snape. At some point during his school years, he decided to reject his father's name entirely, giving himself the moniker "The Half-Blood Prince" with his mother's maiden name instead. Meanwhile, other characters, like Harry, try to unmask him. Suspicions were aroused at every turn by the level of enmity Snape felt toward Harry, but a piece of the puzzle was revealed when readers learned that Snape had a crush on Lilly who had eyes for no one but Harrys father. Several factors combine to give him powerful charisma, from his eerie, snake-like appearance to his merciless attitude to his powerfully compelling ideas and force of will. Snape getting 100%, completely, unequivocally rejected is kind of a huge thing in the story, the guy could barely get her to talk to him most of the time past a certain point, let alone them going at it in Filch's broom closet. Snape's adult life at Hogwarts is craftily disguised as a Professor who despises Harry, when in fact Snape loves Harry and has determined, at Dumbledore's request, to save Harry at all costs, including death. Select from the 0 categories from which you would like to receive articles. In his dying moments, Snape asks Harry to look at him clearly a reference to Lily, in that Harry's eyes resemble his mother's and gives him a vial of memories. In the aftermath of the battle, Harry gets the chance to live out his life, get married, and have children, and his second youngest son, Albus Severus, carries on Snape's legacy, especially as Harry tells his son that he named him for two of the bravest men he'd ever met. You can't make him a saint: he was vindictive & bullying. So no harry;s father was definitly not Severus Snape. Are some of the characters real heroes? Tonk's patrous turned into a wolf but for awhile people thought she had been in love with her cousin Sirus but in reality it was Lupin. Despite Ron's and Hermione's doubts, Harry is correct that Voldemort himself has enlisted Draco with a task, though he doesn't know that task is until it's too late. What seemed to be a childrens story has now become a dark and nuanced one. However, Snape's life takes a turn when he meets a young Lily Evans, who lives nearby. If it's the former that's actually one of my favorite scenarios, I don't read fanfiction much but. Now having to deal with being the father of a man old enough to be his own father. As far as readers and viewers know, Snape was the only Death Eater to cast a Patronus spell throughout the series. But where do his real loyalties lie? I am wondering the same thing about Snape being Harry's father after watching all of the movies, and even after reading everyone's response about this idea being ludicrous. Explicitly. Something a father would do. This way, Draco's soul would be spared. Biologically: James Potter - the father who's blood Harry carries and respectively calls "dad". It is unclear why Snape is still alive in the alternate reality where Voldemort won the wizarding war, given that Voldemort should have still killed him as he believed that Snape was the master of the Elder Wand and still desired to become the wand's master. Why would anyone think that?!?!?! Accessed 4 Mar. That's because Snape has always liked Lily since childhood. What is the summary for Chapter 11 of Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. Notably, though, it also adds to the image of young James Potter, who was kind of theworst. Patronus doesn't indicate bloodline. Snape entered the Leaky Caldron. Severus is born the son of the witch Eileen Prince and the Muggle Tobias Snape. That would have been a brilliant twist! from a genetic standpoint, it seems unusual Harry has coal black hair color, like Snape, when his alleged parents each possess the gene for red hair as seen in the movie showings of Lily and James when they were children. In the books, Snape is one of the youngest teachers to be recruited at Hogwarts school. (I did read the books awhile ago and recently watched the movies). He also learns that Snape's doe Patronus, after Lily's own Patronus, appeared to Harry in the woods and guided him towards Gryffindor's sword. Actually he did meet Lily again after he called her mudblood. It must have said Severus Snape. The ultimate dark wizard, Lord Voldemort, has the strongest villain-style charisma in the Harry Potter world. He turned out to be more of a good guy than fans initially thought, and his somewhat sticky past with Harry's father was revealed which did not paint James in a good light at all. Snapes dual nature has been present throughout the saga. Harry inherited the stag form from James. This shows that, sometimes, our senses deceive us. In a 2007 interview with Bloomsbury, Rowling joked that Skeeter would probably have gone on to write a biography titled "Snape: Scoundrel or Saint?" Snape works a bit like Dumbledores antithesis. From the beginning I knew that the movies wouldn't do justice to J Rowlings masterpiece. He also conducts industry interviews, is a Rotten Tomatoes certified film critic, and knows a LOT about the X-Men. No! This partially influenced her decision to make Snape a hated teacher among Hogwarts students, especially Harry the Potions Master. It's obvious Snape is NOT Harrys father. Snape's responsibilities include monitoring the welfare and discipline of those in Slytherin House and just generally assuming charge of the students. Spoilers for the Harry Potter film & books to follow! Plus, Snape was never the true master of the Elder Wand, due to the fact that Dumbledore, who was dying of a terrible curse, asked Snape to kill him when the time came. RELATED: Harry Potter: 10 Facts About the Potters Left Out Of The Movies. A/N: I do not own any of the characters in this fanfiction except for the original character that I have named Savannah Snape. The Elder Wand, which he stole from Dumbledore's tomb, won't work for him because he isn't the true "master" of it. Alan Rickman was, without a doubt, magnificent as Severus Snape and a perfect guardian of Rowlings secret. For all these reasons and more, we can say that Severus Snape is one of the most complete and fascinating characters in the Harry Potter universe. Seeing as he was a double agent, this also fits. Were drip-fed with information about his past bit by bit. Ultimately, the tension between Snape, Lily, and Petunia comes to a head when Petunia, jealous of Snape's and Lily's respective magical abilities, spies on the two friends. While he had a sudden redemption arc before his . Severus Snape is one of the most intriguing characters in the Harry Potter saga. Latest answer posted July 02, 2009 at 8:18:46 AM. His father was neglectful and sometimes abusive, which may have contributed to Snape's disdain for Muggles. And he killed Dumbledore. However she took that knowledge to her grave. Plus, in the movies we saw that he looked EXACTLY like James. Amongst Severus Snape's possessions that he kept at his home was a curious object called a, Snape's death takes place in the school's. It could have been easy to mix up Snape's confession of a decades long unrequited love for the pair of them having been in love. So, Be nice don't laugh at people beacause they don't know what happened in the book, next time you could be the clueless individual. The Harry Potter saga grows in perfect harmony with its main character. I guess I just read it wrong. A new species of crab has been named after Snape. Now Voldemort's apparent right-hand man, Snape is named the new headmaster of Hogwarts, which puts him in the perfect position to silently help Harry with the aid of Dumbledore's moving portrait, painted after his death. Severus and Lily were also close in age. I think the doe petronus shared by Snape and Lily can have another less sinister explanation than Snape is Harry's father. Since his happiest and most loving memories were with Harry's mother, Lily, his Patronus took the same form as hers which is what made Harry follow it in the first place. Her reply ignited a huge debate among Twitters legion of Harry Potter fans, prompting Rowling to tell them to never change.. In Half-Blood Prince, Harry states that Snape's mother, Eileen Prince, was Pureblood. Lilys parents were Muggles (non-magical people) and when people discovered she was a witch, then a whole world of strange names opened up to her. Not close enough to affect patronus though - or all wizards and witches who aren't muggle born would have the same form. What scene ??'._. Thoughts? He named Albus Severus because he admired Snape's courage in spying, and possibly felt guilty for having doubted and hated the man throughout his life. Tobias Snape was a British Muggle and the patriarch of the Snape family in the late twentieth century. He'd have been mean to Harry deliberately to prevent anyone from guessing the truth from favouritism then, I guess. Alan Rickman, the actor who brought the character to life, was the only one . Harry paid him tribute in forgiveness and gratitude. While Snape may have protectedHarry partially out of hisenduring love for Lily, his debt to James can't be understated -- and was directly referenced asthe reason why Snape savedHarryfrom Quarrel in the novel version ofHarry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone. In 2007, when asked by a fan . Snape was a half-blood, born to a Muggle father named Tobias Snape and a witch mother named Eileen Prince. Maybe Voldemort is Harry`s father. The Harry Potter books and movies are filled with unforgettable characters, from students like Hermione Granger and bullies like Draco Malfoy to professors like Minerva McGonagall and the villainous Lord Voldemort. 15 Books for Your Oscar Season Reading List, How We Can Learn to Live with COVID-19 After Vaccinations. When Harry explores them, he learns everything he needs to know. In a series of tweets, Rowling explained her reasoning. Having taught at Hogwarts for fourteen years in. Next Ron and Hermione, sittin' in a tree. Who asks this kind of question? In this 'Snape is the father of Harry story' nobody knows that Snape is the father of Harry. It has just dawned on me that JK Rowling drops tons of clues during the series that Snape could be Harrys father, not James as we are initially led to believe. The question isn't judging people who don't read the books. The D answers by saying its not curious at all. This relationship will be key to discovering more about Snape as an adult in the Harry Potter saga. However, what he doesn't know is that Snape is secretly helping him. By using our Services, you agree to our use of cookies. However, she had a huge secret prepared that change everything. The Harry. Lily knows that Snape is the father of Harry. Ultimately, Albus Severus as detailed in the Tony Award-winning play Harry Potter and the Cursed Child is sorted into Slytherin just like one of this two namesakes, eventually becoming close friends with Scorpius Malfoy (Draco's son) and setting off on a time-bending adventure befitting his father and both of the men for whom he was named. Rowling described him in one 2015 tweet as "grey," with both saint-like and devil-like tendencies. In the film, as Harry is holding a dying Snape in his arms, the professor uses his final words to repeat a line we've heard from several other characters throughout the series: "You have your mother's eyes.". Thus, were faced with the question: Who really is who in Harry Potter? But even so, he sticks to his promise and helps Harry survive a harrowing first year at Hogwarts. Fury of the Gods Special: Shazamily Matters, 25 Years Ago, Michelle Yeoh Starred in James Bond's Most Underrated Movie, 10 Worst Written Female Characters In An Action Movie. Of course, when Sirius eventually escapes, Snape is livid, creating even more tension between him and Harry. Horrified, Harry tries to chase Snape, but he disappears with his fellow Death Eaters. He harshly punishes know-it-alls like Hermione and those he considers to be stupid or unintelligent. you'll get it later. But if they don't quit asking, tell them to tell you the reason why they think Snape is Harry's father. However, of all of the characters in Harry Potter, few are as fascinating as Severus Snape, the Slytherin potions master who seems like one of the cruelest villains for nearly the entire series. However, Snape was truly a part of the Order of the Phoenix and . Would love to hear what anyone else thinks about it. Theres no way lily would cheat on James. Snape loved Harry's mother Lily, so that is why he figures himself as the father of Harry. He was a double agent, so many character details were kept a secret. This would likely explain his hostility towards Peter in. Because it seems like a interesting idea. With Dumbledore's help, Snape manages to hide the Sword of Gryffindor in a forest for Harry to find, enabling him to destroy horcruxes (because the sword is strengthened by basilisk venom) and keep track of Harry in general, quietly assisting him in his mission to weaken Voldemort enough to finally bring him down. Quickly, the two become close friends, and Snape tells Lily, a Muggle-born witch, about Hogwarts and their future there together. But based on the description of the position on Wizarding World, it seems like Snape was destined for the role. This is eventually revealed to be a by-product of Snape's lingering resentment for Harry's father, James -- who had been a major rival to Snape in their youth. Like the Harry/Hermione love think. Sometime before 1960, pure-blood witch Eileen Prince married Muggle Tobias Snape. Harry Potter Wiki is a FANDOM Movies Community. Doesnt he look just like James, with Lilys eyes? Is he a spy for Dumbledore or for Voldemort? This is repeated again and again until his death. I wish Snape was his father becuase I dont like James. Well hope this wasn't to bad I tried my best. Also the doe spell (can't spell it) matches lilys who he can mean a multiple of things. He was a pure-blood wizard married to Lily Evans Potter, Harry's mother. Lily was a Muggleborn while Snape was halfblood. It's questions like this that make Snape Rowling's richest creation. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. In Snape's memories, there was a lot to do with Lily in there. In the Harry Potter series, one of the main antagonists is Severus Snape. Did Snape steal sword? i think people got confused bc they gave alot of details on how snape and lily were really close friends and snape really did love her. Snape is not Harry Porter's father but to make it clear, James Potter is his father. Rowling said that if Snape didn't love Lily he wouldn't have protected or even have been remotely interested in what happened to Harry. Even just from his name, Snape, it sounds like snake, usually associated with evil. Rowling plays around with the questions in our minds. Tonks' patronus is another example of tragic/unrequited love changing a patronus. It's definitely Snape. I'd imagine if that be the truth then Snape wouldn't treat his son like shit, Who did Harry see in the mirror of Erised? What made the fans who didnt read the book think that way ?? eNotes.com will help you with any book or any question. All the latest gaming news, game reviews and trailers. Despite being rivals in the backstory of the Harry Potter series, James Potter's rescue of Severus Snape was a quietly vital moment. James was probably a jerk to Snape because he sensed that Snape was in love with Lily. This thread is archived I Saw People Saying That on Tumblr before I Saw or even Read The Final Book, So That was a Shock. DD says.don't tell me you've come to care for the boy. Why not? My thoughts were Snape loved Lily would do anything for her so sacrificing himself wouldn't be far fetched and I cant imagine disguising a dead body would be difficult. With our Essay Lab, you can create a customized outline within seconds to get started on your essay right away. That part of the story where we finally understand everything Snape has done, and where we realize why Dumbledore had protected him so much, has become one of the most applauded by fans of the saga. Snape is pedantic, arrogant, and lacks empathy. Harry has the same patronus as James. Because the movies leave out more than half the details from the books. Snape may have been a villain throughout his life, but Harry made sure to remember him as a hero. Just no. Also, he's compared to James all the time, saying that they're practically identical other than eye colour and scar. In The Chamber Of Secrets, I'm pretty sure that it says that Harry looks nothing like the Dursleys, or nothing like his surviving family, not that he resembles no one in his family. Press J to jump to the feed. Rupert Grint admitted to being afraid of him in an interview. Though Snape begs for her forgiveness, particularly because Lily was defending him against James, he can't justify hurting Lily, and she gives up on him for good. J.K. Rowling stated that Lily Evans may have grown to love Snape romantically if he was not so drawn to the Dark Arts. And that's whenSnape shows up and does the job himself. Because they ship Snape and Lily, despite the fact that it was Lily and James who got married, not Lily and Snape. Although we know he wasn't always this way, Snape seemed to have grown into the position quite comfortably by Harry's first year. He abused her mentally and emotionally, as Harry Potter saw in . Cookies help us deliver our Services. The Potions Professor at Hogwarts despite his history as a former member of Voldemort's Death Eaters, Snape is shown to have a personal distaste for Harry specifically.This is eventually revealed to be a by-product of Snape's lingering resentment for Harry's father, James -- who had . *sigh* new in fandom, just wait a few months. I know for a second I was thinking the same thing but in all the movies & books they say he's a spitting image of James but has his mothers eyes. Haven't they read Philisiphers Stone? Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix, Harry Potter Page to Screen: The Complete Filmmaking Journey, LEGO Harry Potter: Building the Magical World, LEGO Harry Potter: Characters of the Magical World, Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part 1, Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part 2, Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald, Fantastic Beasts: The Secrets of Dumbledore, Magic Beyond Words: The J.K. Rowling Story, Fantastic Beasts: Cases from the Wizarding World, Creator: Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets, Attack on Godric's Hollow (1981) participants, Battle of the Astronomy Tower participants, Defence Against the Dark Arts Professors at Hogwarts, Plot to assassinate Albus Dumbledore participants, Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry, Department for the Regulation and Control of Magical Creatures, Murder of Severus Snape in Shrieking Shack, http://www.accio-quote.org/articles/2007/0726-today-vieira1.html. I'm genuinely curious as he was nothing but abusive towards everyone.. In modern times, they resided in a house on Spinner's End. On twitlonger Rowling said that when Snape went to meet with Dumbledore on the windy hilltop he was still a subscriber to the inhuman philosophy of Voldemort. Though Harry, Ron, and Hermione are convinced that Snape is working with Voldemort to try to steal the stone, it turns out that Professor Quirrell, the Defense Against the Dark Arts teacher, is the one actually searching for the magical item as he's possessed by the weak, bodiless spirit of the Dark Lord. However, it's never clearly mentioned in the books, probably because Slughorn only liked to show off the students he was most proud of. In Harry's fifth year, now that Voldemort has officially returned, it's more important than ever for "the Boy Who Lived" to protect himself against the Dark Lord, who's skilled in the art of legilimency (meaning that he can delve into Harry's thoughts at any time). " He just headed up to his room, room number 234". Professor Slughorn, his Potions Master, was very fond of both Snape and Lily, so they were both likely a part of his elite student group, the Slug Club. The movie watchers are confused, just as I am, because when Harry is in the pensive with Snape's memories, Snape and DD are talking. Rowling fooled us all, making us believe that Snape was a real villain and that all he wanted was for Harry to suffer. It's likely however that he learned the truth following Voldemort's rebirth as he showed much less hostility towards Sirius than before (while still a significant amount) and he was made aware that Peter was alive and on the side of the Death Eaters. You can't see why they would think Snape is Harry's father I can (Flashes of Snape with Lily seem to indicate there was something between them and then Dumbledore says don't tell Harry the secret) come on people you couldn't be that lame that's what they do in movies leave something to the imagination. When the year draws to a close, Harry and Sirius come face to face, flanked by Ron, Hermione, and Lupin, and a shocking realization comes to light. Rather than attending Hogwarts for his seventh and final year, Harry continues the work he started with Dumbledore and hunts down Voldemort's horcruxes, objects containing pieces of the Dark Lord's soul. Charley Gallay/Getty Images; Warner Bros. A 'Harry Potter' costume designer breaks down iconic looks worn by Voldemort, Bellatrix, and more of the films' villains, 18 little-known facts about Voldemort even die-hard 'Harry Potter' fans may not know, 28 major 'Harry Potter' movie deaths, ranked from least to most heartbreaking, 27 details the 'Harry Potter' movies got totally wrong, Severus Snape is one of the most divisive characters in the entire, His mother was a witch and his father was a Muggle, leading to the moniker "The Half-Blood Prince. A Professor at Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry, Snape is hostile to Harry due to his resemblance to his father James Potter. Is Snape Harry's Father? [21] In addition, Harry later named his second son Albus Severus Potter in honour of Dumbledore and Severus, both of whom were an inspiration in Harry's life after the Battle of Hogwarts. The Harry Potter novelist shed light on Twitter over the epilogue to Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, which revealed that Harry named his son Albus Severus. Maybe a way of coming clean? Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our, Digital What is the setting of Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets? Our suspicions are confirmed when we discover that Severus Snape is indeed one of them, and that he even murdered the person who had always trusted him: Albus Dumbledore. And maybe they thought that because of Snapes memories of Lily and how he really did Love her and still did until he died. Harry is Snape's father Just read a fic where Harry got thrown back in time and fell in love with Eileen Prince and fathered Snape. Although i would have found it interesting if he was though but sadly he's not so there you have it. Rowling has shared a number of revelations since the Harry Potter books and films wrapped upincluding the fact that Dumbledore was gay. Snape and Lily make a better couple. I typed in "When Harry finds out" And the search engine top result was "When Harry finds out Snape is his father" Thank goodness it was wrong Ok, Snape was a death eater and if the death eaters and voldermont were the people who killed Harry's mum and dad why would snape help kill his wife and attempt to help voldermont kill harry obvioulsly guys THINK, I happen to know exactly how you feel since my DAD and sister feel that snape is the real father. New Movie News, Movie Trailers & upcoming Movie Reviews, Harry Potter: How Harrys Father Saved Snapes Life, An Iconic Harry Potter Role Was Nearly Played By Successions Brian Cox, Harry Potters Most Powerful Potion Might Be The Reason He Ended Up With Ginny, Harry Potter And The Cursed Child Star Fired Over Misconduct Allegations, REVIEW: Frank Miller Presents Ancient Enemies: The Djinni #1 Crafts a Compelling Origin Story, REVIEW: DC's Shazam! lol. Of course Harry cast a glamour on him and was thrown back to the present. The only difference in their appearances is the different eye colour and the scar. The answer is simple, though harry looks a bit like James, he has more of snappes features, as you see in the movie Lilly and James are very alike so just because they say he is like his "father " they might just se his mothers features instead. Why can't Harry see thestrals before he saw Cedric dying, because he saw his mum dying?