Those are three great choices and you can't go wrong with any of them. On the other hand, the Yoder grills are surely more heavy-duty, but they are the best for commercial use. Pitts and Spitts grills can reach temperatures of over 600 degrees, and the pellet grates are very simple to clean. I know people have asked the question before about the PID and the general response has been that the yoder firmware is better. Learn more. Side to side and front to back, you can grill up a meal with the same grilling intensity across the entire grilling when needed. This page was generated at 02:20 AM. The same cannot be said about the Yoder group. Awesome, just ordered the 1250 with smoke box! This pellet grill can be used for commercial purposes and although this is expensive but considering the quality, it is worth going for. These three brands have reputation for providing high-quality cooking appliances however Yoder grill is considered more expensive. These two grilling appliances and companies have been used by professionals over the years, but there has to be something that makes each product stands out. This grill manufacturer prioritizes quality over quantity, which is why these grills are so impressive. Their grills have been increasingly popular over time. I looked at the RT-700, the Yoder YS-640S, and the Pitts & Spitts Maverick 1250. Love the Yoder, but also like the look of the Maverick. Click here to read our detailed review and the raves from people who own them. On the other hand, the Yoder grills come with steel construction. So, lets compare their prime specifications below to pick the winner. *ON TOPIC ONLY* QUALITY ON TOPIC discussion of Backyard BBQ, grilling, equipment and outdoor cookin' . Lots of choices for that first smoke, for me, I'd suggest either a butt or a couple of racks of St Louis ribs. Pitts and Spitts are one of the reliable American companies in terms of Smoker and different types of Grills. Wasnt looking at the Pitts and Spitts, but the option to have direct grilling was a big reason I went with the YS640. When I got it I was amazed that the quality of workmanship/design was the same high quality of my 1250. We provide you the best reviews on kitchen products and kitchen faucets. Pitts and Spitts grills are made in Texas and happen to be the only wood pellet smoker in Texas too. No issues at all if you use the full bottom grate and then 3 half grates. Unlike most other smokers in this segment, it charges a bit more which is not so budget-friendly. Otherwise, for regular household usage, a P&S pellet smoker is a great purchase, indeed. Im driving from FL to DC after thanksgiving and stopping at a dealer on the way to take a look. Choosing between Pitts and Spitts or Yoder grill is not meant to be complex as these two offer the same value although different prices and functionality. I still have hellfire (weber s670) for that if needed!!!! Material These grills are also available at a reasonable price. Cooking capacity is another point that differs between Pitts and Spitts grills and Yoder grills. Pitts & Spitts Minnesota. Copyright 2023 Loving Food | Powered by Foodies. Yes! Based on what I've read, I believe the P&S has more even temps and for me has a better overall feature set and would be my choice if buying. On the Yoder, youll have a larger searing area that is very intense. REC TEC actually performs better in this category than Traeger does because its grills have a temperature range of between . You are using an out of date browser. On the contrary, a Yoder wood pellet grill seals the deal by offering more long-lasting construction and better temperature control. Post your hints, tips, tricks & techniques, success, failures, but stay on topic and watch for that hijacking. Nice, let us see/know how it works for you. Living up to the reputation of Yoder, it boasts extraordinary temperature control with industry-leading connectivity. Actually, the heavy-duty construction of the cook box is the reason behind it. So, in terms of great value for money, P&S products are preferable. Yoder grill is designed for heavy use makes it an ideal option for you if you are going to be smoking lots of meat and cooking too. If you are looking for a grill having extended cooking and hopper capacity, Pitts and Spitts grills can fulfill your demand. > Discussion Area > Q-talk Pitts and Spitts vs. Yoder (pellet) Register FAQ Calendar Mark Forums Read Notices Welcome to BBQ Brethren's Forums. With all the grates there is plenty of room though. Pitts and spitts vs rec tec. Click here to read our detailed review and the raves from people who own them. I have seen them in a shop and they feel much more sturdy than Traeger and the like. Great direct drill, excellent smoker, just limited in smoking capacity. I'm with you on many of the other pellet cookers they just feel flimsy, I know they cook great food but there is something about opening the lid on a substantial pit that is very satisfying. MAK is the Bently of pellet poopers. No such thing as a perfect cooker so ya really just have to decide what you can live with/without. WD Purple vs Seagate Skyhawk: Best Surveillance Hard Drive, Seagate Ironwolf vs Barracuda: Best Storage Solution, Oklahoma Joe Longhorn vs Highland: Which One You Should Buy. Yoder YS640 vs Pitts and Spitts 850 Curious what peoples thoughts are on the yoder vs p&s. I see yoder had lots of paints issues but just spoke to them and they said they've improved their painting process. As a BBQ pit, which one will you choose from Pitts and Spitts vs Yoder? Share cooks, recipes, your smoker setup, anything related to Yoder smokers and grills, Press J to jump to the feed. They are hand made in Wichita, KS. Now lets take a look at different types of grills and their functionalities manufactured by these two companies. These two grills come with almost the same features and price tag. Its among the best bargains for a smoker in the world. I got to be up close and personal with a Yoder YS-640 last yearthey are built like a tank. Here we put an end to the debate of Pitts and Spitts VS Yoder. The beauty of the Flat Top is the fire table moves up and down and makes control much easier. Yoder YS640 vs Pitts and Spitts Maverick 1250 Hi all, I've been planning to purchase a YS640 for quite some time but have recently came across the Pitts and Spitts Maverick 1250 and it seems to be a really well built smoker. We have a rigorous product testing regimen. If theres a Black Friday sale I may just pull the trigger. On the other hand, P&S products are also decent in terms of longevity. Pitts & Spitts has a direct grilling option and is cheaper than Yoders ($124.99 vs $189.00) Pitts an Spitts, Yoder - Pitmaster Club By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. This is more of an inconvenience than a real negative. 327 74K views 5 years ago I received some questions about why I chose the Pitts and Spitts New Pellet Grill vs the Yoder YS 640. They make everything from backyard smokers to portable kitchens you need a fifth-wheel to haul. To make this argument as fair as possible, we compared two of their flagship grills for your better understanding. PITTS & SPITTS HAS BEEN A LEGEND IN THE BBQ BUSINESS FOR NEARLY 40 YEARS. If I were going to go away from Yoder, it would be a Mak or Memphis, not saying they are better or worse, because I really don't know, but they have been in the pellet game for a long time, and make good cookers. Pellet Smoker Cook-Off | Yoder vs Weber vs GMG vs Pitts & Spitts 3 Year Pellet Grill Review | Pitts & Spitts Pellet Grill Review I Ate the Best Barbecue in the World | Mad Scientist. Comments on this forum helped me figure out that I wanted it for smoking, and I'm happy to use my Weber for grillin. I saw both in person and the yoder seems like it would handle grilling better plus it has the integrated fireboard which is a nice plus. SmokingMeatForums.com is a community of barbecue and outdoor cooking enthusiasts dedicated to smoking meat. Pitts and Spitts vs. Yoder (pellet) - The BBQ BRETHREN FORUMS. ** Other cooking techniques are welcomed for when your cookin' in the kitchen. So, if you are interested in investing in a new grill, continue reading this article and get the perfect grill at your home! The MAK 2 Star will most likely handle the amount of meat you will be smoking. In fact, many of their smoking accessories have won some international prestigious competitions due to their incredible workmanship. Thats what makes the expensive price tag justified. Shipping Is Not Available For This Product. And they are architectured with high-quality materials to last longer. Gotta respect that. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. If you cant decide between these two grills, youll need to compare them. If you are considering a grill based on how long it has been in the market then you might just go with Pitts and Spitts, however, that is not all you need to pick an efficient grill. If you are interested in a Pitts & Spitts Pellet Grill and have any questions you can contact: +1 (832)-214-8590 for more information. I've read the reviews already on both. The Yoder grill might be a great option for restaurant needs, although there are also small portable sizes you can go for. Just my 2 cents :). I have had it for over a year and couldn't be happier. Authorized Distributor For Pitts and Spitts Smokers and Grills. The Yoder pellet grill has a warranty of 10 years which is one of its most amazing features. When I say offset on the Pitts, I am referring to the opening not being directly over the fire like it is on the Yoder. WHEN WE WENT SHOPPING FOR A LOG PIT A FEW YEARS AGO, OUR CHOICE WAS ULTIMATELY THE PITTS & SPITTS ULTIMATE SMOKER, A GENUINE GEM. Being a member of both groups on Facebook, I noticed that pretty much all of the posts on the P&S group were of people enjoying everything about it. If you value the terrific construction quality, Yoder should be your pick. Therefore, they will let you smoke longer. But the most distinctive feature of this pellet grill is the opportunity to direct over the flame grilling. There are now 3 things that test a marriage. Yoder Smokers is a reliable grills and smoker accessories supplier company. I have had zero issues with it, and everything that has come off of it has been amazing. Here we also compared these two companies and their products. I like a lot of the other things about it too..on paper anyhow. Yoder grills are made from chrome-plated steel and powder-coated steel with a single layer lid. Your email address will not be published. To set you up for ultimate success, we also offer high quality wood pellets, grill grates, and a local Texas spice line. Smoking Brisket At 250 vs 225 | The Difference Will Amaze You! If grilling were not so important to me, hands down Id take the Pitts. Need to add a pellet to the arsenal. Can't imagine going wrong with either. He asked me what I didn't like about the GMG other than being made overseas..temp fluctuations. Traeger Ironwood 650 vs Pro 575 | Which One Is Best For Grilling? JavaScript is disabled. But to stay on the safe side of things, here are safety tips and a manual that can help care for your grill. You guys provide one HELL of a SUPERB smoker! Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. I have an older Yoder and it is a tank. Outside of that, Im looking for pros and cons of these and hoping to hear from current or previous owners. Pitts & Spitts Copyright 2022 | Site by Batch Creative. It gets plenty hot right at that spot, and the thick steel deflector plate and drip pan spread out the heat nicely, but superhot searing capability is still limited to a relatively small area. Frogmats 3 Pack 16x16 Non Stick BBQ Grill Smoker Mats Traeger & Rec Tec Frogmat. It is top notch. Our talented team of paid moderators will be with you shortly. I am happy to answer any questions you may have about the P&S. As you already know, its a competition-grade pellet grill to offer an unfailing smoking experience both at home and beyond. Disaster Relief Dinner: Blackened Filet Mignon (Lotsa Pics @ Lotsa Dialog), Pellet Grill Wont Get Up To Temp. P&S started with the Smoke Daddy hopper and controller. The Pitts and Spitts seem well built (like a Yoder without the paint problems) bit are very expensive. Yoder Smokers have triumphed on some of the worlds most prestigious competition stages, making huge numbers of backyard chefs envy their community. It is said that Yoder smokers are built to last. I see yoder had lots of paints issues but just spoke to them and they said they've improved their painting process. little help please. Both these bard manufacture grills with unique design concepts. I am willing to bet that whichever way you go, you will learn to make it dance for you :). Yoder is well-known for its patented Adaptive Control Scheme, which the company claim gives improved flexibility, effectiveness, and precision. Heat the grill for 15 minutes for indirect cooking. Please use them. Personally, I do not think you will beat a MAK as a smoker AND everyday grill. I still think the trap door assembly on the Yoder for direct flame sear is a better design than the P&S which requires you to move the shield to access the flame after you remove the trap door. We go a step further. ON ALL OF THE HOUSTON COMPANYS PRODUCTS, THE CRAFTSMANSHIP IS OUTSTANDING IN LOOKS, DURABILITY, AND CAPABILITY. One significant difference between the two pellet grills is the temperature range. Masterbuilt vs Bradley Smoker: The Ultimate Smoking Tool For A Better BBQing Experience. The bigger the hopper capacity, the longer burn the grill offers. If you have business or technical issues, please contact us with this email form. There has been quite a lot of comparison between Pitts and Spitts vs Yoder grill, but none seems to be hitting the surface for people. Yoder, which was founded in 2007, focuses on producing competition-quality smokers. He had a Yoder then sold it after 6 months to get the 1250. This is a wood grill, and it makes use of real wood which helps it produce a great smokey flavor you cant help but love. I'm interested in this thread but don't have experience with either of these cookers. In comparison to pellet grills, gas grills are usually less expensive, quicker, and can reach greater temperatures. As these two pellet grills are of similar features and represent their respective brands, we can easily conclude that the Pitts and Spitts products offer more hopper capacity. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising.