Johnson was accused of planning to sell the NHS. What are Johnson and Corbyn promising you? Weve heard it time and time again from the Labour Party. My conclusion is that there are very different explanations for how two people so obviously unsuited to high office became leaders of our two great political parties. ", Mr Johnson added: "Under no circumstances will we sell it off to anybody in any kind of trade deal. There are currently 39,500 nursing vacancies in the NHS in England. He later suggested that Mr Johnson was pursuing a Canada-style deal which he said took seven years to negotiate. The PM's deal was supported by 285 Conservative MPs, 19 Labour MPs and 25 independents.. 3. You deserve better. Mr Corbyn and Mr Johnson also share an ability to drive opponents to near insanity. In the case of Labours selectocracy, the desire was for unashamed socialism. Both Labour and the Tories plan to raise public spending back to 1970s levels, according to the Resolution Foundation. Copyright 2010-2023 Full Fact. Home of the Daily and Sunday Express. After two weeks of campaigning there has been relatively little movement in the polls, with some of Labours improvement accounted for by pollsters such as ICM returning to the market, whose figures show a smaller gap than those of YouGov. Not from what we're hearing We're told Nadine Dorries' attack on Hunt on Monday - in which she accused him of being duplicitous - was directly authorised by Number 10." What is Boris Johnson's net worth as Prime Minister resigns | Evening Corbyn will leave Labour as a fright-wig tribute to 1970s-era Militant tendency with the worst absurdities of 2010s-era campus identity politics grafted on. Similarly, 75% are dissatisfied with how the Johnson government is running the country compared to 18% that are satisfied. But Mr Johnson was met with applause from the audience when he said he found it "slightly curious" to be lectured about the union by Mr Corbyn, referring to the Labour leader's past support for those who want to see a united Ireland. (Reader, she was making it up.) During the debate, the Prime Minister claimed a Labour government would disband MI5 and back the early release of convicted terrorists and accused the Labour leader of having supported the IRA throughout his political career. The Conservative leader said a government run by him would "encourage nurses overseas to come" to the UK "by shortening the time for their visa applications" and by reintroducing bursaries for training. We cant say definitively whether that would be possible, but the independent think tank the Institute for Government has described that timetable as hard to meet. When a leadership challenge was launched Mr Corbyns opponents alighted on Owen Smith, then the mp for Pontypridd, as a candidate. Mr Corbyn did not specify which comments he was referring to but Mr Johnson has been widely criticised for articles he wrote referring to "piccaninnies" and likening Muslim women in burqas to letterboxes and bank robbers. The prime minister and his Labour challenger argued their case to lead the UK in the first televised debate of the general election campaign. Plaid Cymru's Liz Saville Roberts said the debate felt like a "shoddy end-of-term pantomime", and said both men displayed a "lack of honesty". Johnson and Corbyn locked in unpopularity contest, polls suggest Such derangement has echoes of Labour figures in 2019 who, in the wake of their worst result since 1935, claimed that the party had won the argument. How Boris Johnson won -- and Jeremy Corbyn lost | CNN Other topics covered included the NHS, security and Northern Ireland. Jeremy Corbyn was once again pressed on his failure to pick a side on Brexit - and questioned on why Europe would offer Labour a new deal when so many frontbenchers back Remain. THE FACTS: The Labour leader has repeatedly accused Johnson of using Brexit to sell out the NHS and its workers to the US. But Mr Johnson was met with applause from the audience when he said he found it "slightly curious" to be lectured about the union by Mr Corbyn, referring to the Labour leader's past support for those who want to see a united Ireland. The fact that 41% of Conservative mps opposed him in a confidence vote in June can therefore be dismissed. A weekly round-up of some of the best articles featured in the most recent issue of the New Statesman, sent each Saturday. Mr Johnson told how he had been pushing for an end to short sentences for terrorists long before he became Prime Minister. Mr Corbyn said the choice was "not an either/or". As such, he became the pragmatists choice and, on the test of electability, they were proven right. UK ministers have said it wont be on the table, and its unlikely a deal would wholly redesign the NHS. Like Brexit, the NHS has featured heavily in the campaign so far - and Friday's debate was no different. The ineptitude of his internal enemies was the main reason Mr Corbyn stayed in power. The EUs trade deal with Canada took five years to negotiate, and another two before it was provisionally applied. Boris Johnson's first ratings as a new party leader are actually most similar to Jeremy Corbyn's, who received a score of 33% satisfied, 36% dissatisfied in September 2015. There is no solace for Labour moderates in knowing that their internal process for selecting a new leader will probably produce someone even worse. Can Nigeria's election result be overturned? "And the price of that deal, the price of Nicola Sturgeon's support, would be a second referendum on the union with Scotland. Thats roughly the cash increase that was announced last year for the NHS in England between 2018/19 and 2023/24. All rights reserved. 20 November 2019. How to watch the Question Time under-30s special, Xi Jinping's power grab - and why it matters, Street fighting in Bakhmut but Russia not in control, Russian minister laughed at for Ukraine war claims. Boris Johnson and Jeremy Corbyn accused each other of failing to lead their parties. Boris Johnson could make Jeremy Hunt chancellor. We also expect to write more about what the leaders said over the coming days. He is a. Boris vs Parliament. That doesnt mean a UK-US trade deal necessarily would take as long. Mr Johnson referenced nine years of year-on-year economic growth which is correct. What's the least amount of exercise we can get away with? Many of my former colleagues who voted for him knew that he had substantial inadequacies that in normal times would have disqualified him from becoming Prime Minister. Boris Johnson then said that the Conservatives are putting a record amount of money into the NHS34 billion. WHAT HE SAID: Jeremy Corbyn told Boris Johnson: "You're going to sell our NHS out to the United States and Big Pharma.". Get UK politics insight with our free daily email briefing straight to your inbox. Parliament prorogued: Boris' Brexit bombshell leaves Westminster in (Like Make America Great Again, the slogan can also operate as a neat dog whistle for bigots, who make up a small but active part of every electorate and must, to that end, be catered for by any aspirant government.). Kuenssberg: No fireworks moment in debate, Corbyn and Johnson TV debate fact-checked, Five key things in the BBC's Johnson-Corbyn debate, Who should I vote for? Responding to the performances of Mr Corbyn and Mr Johnson, SNP leader Nicola Sturgeon tweeted: "That was utterly woeful. It's believed that in the case of future trade discussions, US negotiators would want "full market access" for US pharmaceuticals. We heard nothing from Jeremy Corbyn on Brexit. How to get one is not, The union planning Britains biggest rail strikes for three decades, How Boris Johnson undid the Tory Partys mythology, Britains stockmarket has languished. Corbyn vs Johnson: BBC election debate roundup. "And so what he will do is walk out of a relationship with the EU into a relationship with nobody.". Faith, a student nurse in the audience, asked how each leader would deal with a shortage of NHS nurses. Voters sniffed that out. As leaders, both are written off by commentators and rivals alike before enjoying a surprise triumph in an election. Plaid Cymru's Liz Saville Roberts said the debate felt like a "shoddy end-of-term pantomime", and said both men displayed a "lack of honesty". During the last decade, Conservative governments have given the United Kingdom a strange basket of gifts. The Prime Minister said it was "extraordinary" the Chief Rabbi had felt the need to speak out during an election campaign about his fears for his community if Mr Corbyn became prime minister. Weve not seen any robust predictions for how long a UK-US deal would take, and we dont yet know exactly what would be on the table during discussions. 2023 Cable News Network. But Nick Robinson challenged Mr Johnson, pointing out that while he had a withdrawal deal in place, he did not have a trade deal with the EU, and so could not rule out a no-deal exit in January 2021. Anger also flared when Mr Corbyn claimed Brexit could break up the UK. The National Health Service has experienced some of its longest wait times for some types of healthcare visits despite targets to get people treated in a timely manner. Early on in the debate - hosted by Today presenter Nick Robinson - the Labour leader said he would negotiate a new withdrawal agreement with the EU within three months before putting it to a final say referendum - alongside Remain - within six months. Both candidates were asked by an audience member if they would prioritise the safety of citizens over human rights. The UKs corporation tax is not the lowest in Europe. They also concluded, however, that he was best placed to unite the right radicalised by Brexit and win a general election. Since a small fall directly after the financial crisis it has remained relatively stable. Both party leaders made claims about funding the NHS, delivering Brexit and each other's campaign promises. In September 2015 he became Leader of the Labour Party and subsequently Leader of the Opposition. Jeremy Johnson Yet the critics are also right to be furious. Specifically, the one worn by the Labour leader, Jeremy Corbyn. He added the UK could not have security "on the cheap", and so Labour would "back the police up" with an increase in officer numbers. It is a punchy observation and a very good question, one asked by many during the 2019 general election. Long Boris may linger, too. Well be hearing about little green men next, he said. sadiq khan family appreciated. In a fiery head-to-head debate, the Tory leader forced his Labour rival onto the backfoot over Brexit, the economy, national security and the NHS. More info. The answer to Dominic Cummings question is thatLabourdoes not care enough about winning whilethe Conservatives care too much. THE FACTS: Corbyn got this one wrong as all 10 DUP MPs voted against Johnson's deal. He added: "He knows he can't get a deal quickly with the USA because of the way in which the US political system works. Brexit a cause confected almost entirely within the collective psyche of the Tory party has left British politics mudbound, Irish politics teetering on the edge of the most serious crisis since the Troubles of the 1970s and relations with our closest and most important trading partner, the EU, in the toilet. He lost. Public see Johnson as 'most capable PM' vs Corbyn - Ipsos Email webnews@mirror.co.uk. ", Independent Press Standards Organisation (IPSO). And as any Labour mp can confirm, changing leadereven an unpopular onedoes not solve everything. Twitter this morning threatened to ban them from the social media site if they do it again. But Mr Johnson cares little about such disorder. the same question at the tail end of the last couple of weeks, Billing herself as a future prime minister, Winston Churchill, Nelson Mandela, Gareth Southgate and even Vladimir Putin rated more highly. When it came to his turn, Mr Johnson referred to the London Bridge attack, and said it was "extraordinary and wrong" that the attacker was given automatic early release from prison after an earlier terrorism conviction. Mr Corbyn described the NHS as at "breaking point", adding that, under a Labour government, "40bn in total would go into the NHS in order to fund it properly". Mr Corbyn claimed the Prime Minister wanted a trade deal with the US which would take "seven years" to negotiate. Billing herself as a future prime minister appears to have been an overreach. Of course, it is likely to prove no easier to Get Brexit Done than to Make America Great Again, for even with overwhelmingly favorable parliamentary numbers, the next government faces a near-impossible timetable for negotiating a permanent trading arrangement with the European Union by the end of January 2020; a no-deal Brexit is still highly possible. The governments borrowing costs interest rates are at historical lows and economists do not expect a dramatic rise soon. In that sense, the Conservative Party is being true to its traditions it exists to hold power. Johnson's move has sent the ruling class into a frenzied panic. Read about our approach to external linking. His current salary as an elected Member of Parliament of 137,000 is a far cry from his initial starting salary as an MP of only 4,500. The point is that voters have priced in all those things and do not care. Mr Corbyn did, eventually, lead his party to electoral destruction. By Macer Hall , Sam Lister 00:01, Sat, Dec 7, 2019 . People across the country know what this election is about. Jeremy Corbyn net worth: The huge amount Labour leader earns A snap YouGov poll of 1,322 viewers following the debate narrowly gave victory to Mr Johnson by 52% to 48%, although Mr Corbyn was judged the more trustworthy by a margin of 48% to 38%. Jeremy Corbyn attacked Boris Johnson for wanting a trade deal with the USA, which he said would take seven years to negotiate. That needs to change, The autonomous future is nearly here with Wejo, The need to grow Londons EV infrastructure at speed and scale, Dominic Cummings is quick to blame but he fails to understand how government works, The Brexiteers are still living in a fantasy world, Dominic Raabs defenders are wrong being tough doesnt work, Liz Trusss essay shows she is as deluded as ever, The strange death of moderate conservatism Audio Long Reads, Axis of Autocrats: Putin, Xi and Lukashenko, Facility / Grounds Management and Maintenance, HR, Training and Organisational Development, Information and Communications Technology, Information Services, Statistics, Records, Archives, Infrastructure Management - Transport, Utilities, Science and Technical Research and Development. Of the leadership candidates that went forward to Conservative MPs in 2019, Johnson was by far the weakest when it came to executive ability but was the best hope for seeing off Nigel Farage and winning a general election. Chris Curtis, YouGovs Political Research Manager, said: Our snap poll shows that the public remains divided on who won the debate, just as with last month's head-to-head, with most Labour voters thinking Jeremy Corbyn won, most Conservative voters thinking Boris Johnson won, and very few people changing their minds. 11:00 AM EST, Fri December 13, 2019, What you need to know about Boris Johnson, Boris Johnson stars in a new pro-Brexit ad that's a parody of "Love Actually. As Prime Minister, he earns an annual . This means many animal products from Britain need checking at border posts, which carries a fee of at least 47. General election 2019 debate: Corbyn and Johnson fact-checked Was Rishi Sunaks new claim about a house building record accurate? During the live debate, Mr Corbyn said Labour would bring Brexit "to an end" by negotiating a new deal and putting it back to the public in a referendum, alongside a Remain option. The PM's deal was supported by 285 Conservative MPs, 19 Labour MPs and 25 independents. He is also vulnerable to the charge of bitterness, having been forced out of Downing Street in November and reportedly briefed against by Johnson in April. It starts with the manner of their elections to the leadership. That programme is going ahead". To put it most succinctly, the Labour Party does not care enough about winning, the Conservative Party cares too much. Election debate: Johnson and Corbyn clash over Brexit WHAT HE SAID: " Jeremy Corbyn and the Labour Party, be in no doubt about it, in order to secure power and the keys to No10, are going to do a deal - and they probably already have done a deal - with Nicola Sturgeon and the SNP to form a Corbyn-Sturgeon coalition. investment worth 150bn would come flooding into the country (an assertion that is unlikely to survive factchecking). Corbyn vs Johnson debate fact checked: All the claims, lies and half But with up to 3 million viewers expected to tune in and a head-to-head format that allows Johnson and Corbyn many opportunities to challenge each other, there is a real chance of a dramatic moment or two cutting through, to be recycled endlessly online. Boris Johnson and Jeremy Corbyn clash in ITV election debate 39% Boris Johnson, 46% Jeremy Corbyn, 15% Don't know. WHAT HE SAID: Johnson's Brexit deal "narrowly got through the House of Commons with the support of the DUP". Figures from NHS Improvement show there were just under 40,000 nursing vacancies in NHS trusts in England between January and March 2019. Nadine Dorries, the culture secretary and Mr Johnsons staunchest ally, may be the most successful novelist in cabinet since Disraeli, but the comparisons end there. Organising another crack at him will take time. UK election is a 'Love Actually'-esque holiday horror show, The simplest analysis comes down to three B-words. I want to have a government that represents the whole country. Jeremy Corbyn has announced his plans to resign as leader of the Labour party following the party's crushing defeat in the general election. On Brexit, the Prime Minister repeatedly tore into the Labour leader over his dithering Brexit policy. The UKs gini score in 2017/18, after housing costs are taken into account, is 38.6%, slightly down on the 2009/10 score of 40.3%. How Boris Johnson won -- and Jeremy Corbyn lost | CNN Be first in line for the facts get our free weekly email. When it came to his turn, Mr Johnson referred to the London Bridge attack, and said it was "extraordinary and wrong" that the attacker was given automatic early release from prison after an earlier terrorism conviction. In contrast, it was an act of political ruthlessness to make Johnson the Tory leader. The Conservative campaign is revolving heavily around Johnson, to the point where it is not obvious if there is a plan B if he says something flippant on television. The Lockdown Files only confirm every suspicion we had about the pandemic government, Undermining Sue Grays integrity wont save Boris Johnson, SNP leadership candidates need to abandon the independence delusion, Dominic Cummings has confirmed Boris Johnsons utter unfitness for office, Universal Credit falls short of covering the bare essentials. His books include The Templars and The Plantagenets. Follow him on Twitter. Surveys and focus groups say judgments about party leaders loom in voters minds, despite the fact that two years of intense argument about Brexit appear to have soured perceptions about Britains political class. Johnson is one of the most unpopular new prime ministers, going up against one of the most unpopular leaders of the opposition. Boris Johnson and Jeremy Corbyn clashed over Brexit in the final head-to-head debate before the 12 December election. We dont know Labours policy for corporation tax as its manifesto isnt out yet, but its proposal at the last election was to raise corporation tax to 26% by 2020/21, which wouldnt be the highest in Europe. The year is 2019. The Lib Dem leaders ratings plunged from -9 to -23 in a week, according to Deltapoll. President Trump said during his UK visit in June that the NHS would form part of any future negotiations before pulling back a day later. Be that as it may, the Conservatives were the only party who had a Brexit policy that could be explained in three words, and they were rewarded handsomely for it in Leave-voting Labour constituencies Thursday night. To be fair, Cummings is a man of strong opinions; forcefully expressed (just ask Matt Hancock). (See 9.10pm.) I wont dwell on the Labour Party on this occasion, but it was an act of extraordinary self-indulgence for it to elect as leader not just someone intellectually incapable of holding even minor office but someone so obviously unelectable. Using the most common measure for income inequality, inequality has not changed much over the past three decades. Even his strongest supporters rarely challenge the charges but argue that he has other strengths and that, as far as the public are concerned, these faults are priced in. Thanks to Bytemark for donating our web hosting. The view of various officials inside No 10 was if we have the Prime Minister chairing Cobra meetings and he just tells everyone its swine flu, dont worry about it, Im going to get Chris Whitty to inject me live on TV so everyone realises its nothing to be frightened of that would not help serious planning, he told MPs. [See also:Dominic Cummings has confirmed Boris Johnsons utter unfitness for office]. A career in politics is spent on the fringes of their respective parties, communicating with their most loyal fans via columns in the Daily Telegraph (for Mr Johnson) and the Morning Star (for Mr Corbyn). Not all patients will be waiting for operations though: they could also be waiting to receive prescriptions, or counselling. Russian minister laughed at for Ukraine war claims. An audience member asked the two leaders about Islamophobia and anti-Semitism. ", Corbyn: "We will have a final say. His most notable moment in the campaign came when he accidentally implied he had a 29-inch penis. Full Fact fights for good, reliable information in the media, online, and in politics. Here's a concise guide to where the parties stand on key issues like Brexit, education and the NHS. The PM changes his mind ten times a day, and then calls up the media and contradicts his own policy, day after day said Cummings. The opinions expressed in this commentary are solely those of the author. Discovery Company. The civil war that has simmered within the party since Corbyn was elected as leader in 2015 erupted again in the early hours of Friday morning when the scale of Labour's defeat became clear. WHAT WAS SAID: During the debate, ITV presenter Julie Etchingham said the PM's deal would put "a trade border down the Irish Sea". Specifically, the one worn by the Labour leader, Jeremy Corbyn. Election 2019 manifesto guide, US-made cheese can be called 'gruyere' - court, AOC under investigation for Met Gala dress, The children left behind in Cuba's exodus, Saving Private Ryan actor Tom Sizemore dies at 61, Alex Murdaugh's legal troubles are far from over, Nelson's 97th-minute stunner gives Arsenal victory, Walkie Talkie architect Rafael Violy dies aged 78. Jeremy Bernard Corbyn is a British politician who has been the Member of Parliament (MP) for Islington North since 1983. Editors Note: Dan Jones is a UK-based historian and journalist. In Boris Johnson and Jeremy Corbyn, Britain has two contrasting characters who may become prime minister, each with very different ideas about the country's place in the world, from its. "We'll be hearing about 'little green men' next. During the live debate, Mr Corbyn said Labour would bring Brexit "to an end" by negotiating a new deal and putting it back to the public in a referendum, alongside a Remain option. 1 Boris Johnson and Jeremy Corbyn going head to head in the BBC Election Debate in Maidstone Key Points from the BBC debate last night Anti-semitism, Racism and a failure of leadership An. Similar trends are seen across other pollsters: Johnson hovering around zero and Corbyn somewhat lower. Like Brexit, the NHS has featured heavily in the campaign so far - and Friday's debate was no different. He also warned that Britains economy would be plunged into crisis as soon as Mr Corbyn and his hard-Left shadow chancellor John McDonnell took charge in Downing Street. How to get one is not (Jun 25th)The union planning Britains biggest rail strikes for three decades (Jun 18th)How Boris Johnson undid the Tory Partys mythology (Jun 9th), This article appeared in the Britain section of the print edition under the headline "Boz and Jez", Discover stories from this section and more in the list of contents, Over the next few decades, demand is set to slowly leak away, Rishi Sunaks deal softens the Irish Sea border, but not as much as he claims, Scientific know-how has helped some growers, Published since September 1843 to take part in a severe contest between intelligence, which presses forward, and an unworthy, timid ignorance obstructing our progress.. It points out that the 51% to 49% . But Boris has . If we can get a working majority we can get rid of automatic early release for serious and sexual offences and make sure that terrorists serve their full sentence. It was by some way the worst choice offered to the British public in our modern history. The UK's GDP has grown each year since 2010. At the dispatch box Mr Johnson brings up Mr Corbyn whenever he can. Boris Johnson and Jeremy Corbyn have clashed over Brexit in the first TV election debate . Just like Mr Corbyn, Mr Johnson is not a creature of the parliamentary party. Corbyn and McDonnell would start their time in office with an economic crisis, the Prime Minister said.